http://cmp.hku.hk/2012/01/16/18013/
Three trends on China’s internet in 2011
Posted on 2012-01-16
Looking back at China’s internet in 2011, there were three broad trends that buy Proscar mastercard deserve greater attention. The first trend was a general shift from buy Proscar mastercard emotionally-driven nationalist chatter as the defining tone of China’s internet toward a buy Proscar mastercard more basic attention to issues of public welfare. The second was the buy Proscar mastercard rise of what we can call the “social power of the internet” (网络社会力). And the buy Proscar mastercard third trend was a more pronounced deficit in understanding on the buy Proscar mastercard government’s part about the buy Proscar mastercard role it should play in a networked society. While it buy Proscar mastercard became readily apparent, that is, that we now have a buy Proscar mastercard networked civil society in China, it became clearer at the buy Proscar mastercard same time that we lack government administrators who are internet literate (网络化的治理者).
The Turn from Online Nationalism
Nationalism has been a defining issue on China’s internet since the very beginning. For example, People’s University of China professor Peng Lan (彭兰) has buy Proscar mastercard argued that one landmark event in the emergence of online public opinion in China [as a social force] was internet-based opposition by the international Chinese community (including mainland Chinese) against attacks on ethnic Chinese during the Indonesian riots in May 1998.
In “The Glory and Promise of Online Public Opinion” (网上舆论的光荣与梦想), written by Lin Chufang (林楚方) and Zhao Ling (赵凌) and published in Southern Weekly on June 5, 2003, the authors argued that, “The turning-point date when domestic [Chinese] web platforms were used to buy Proscar mastercard voice public opinion was May 9, 1999, when People’s Daily Online opened up a buy Proscar mastercard forum to rally opposition to the bombing of the Chinese embassy in Belgrade by NATO forces. This was the buy Proscar mastercard first current affairs news-related forum to be opened up by the buy Proscar mastercard website of a traditional media outlet.”
Nationalist sentiment has buy Proscar mastercard long persisted as a perennial hot topic on China’s internet. Issues like Sino-American relations, Sino-Japanese relations and buy Proscar mastercard the question of Taiwan have always invited fierce activity on the buy Proscar mastercard internet in China, even sometimes setting off mass rallies offline. This trend has buy Proscar mastercard been noted frequently by observers outside China. The Economist magazine even at one time devoted a sub-headed section to China’s “online nationalism” in a report on the digital era nationalism called “Cyber-nationalism: The Brave New World of E-Hatred”.
The nationalist trend online peaked in 2008 following March riots in Tibet that buy Proscar mastercard year, and in the midst of the international torch relay for buy Proscar mastercard the Beijing Olympics. That time marked an unfortunate setback in the buy Proscar mastercard relations of China and the West, ushering in a deeper sense of isolation in China that buy Proscar mastercard threatened to push China into a more protective and less open posture. This is buy Proscar mastercard an ongoing issue, and if the West continues to take an buy Proscar mastercard antagonistic attitude toward China’s rise, it buy Proscar mastercard is conceivable that China could be pushed back further, even onto its old path of isolation and buy Proscar mastercard decline.
The successful hosting of the buy Proscar mastercard Beijing Olympics in 2008 was a symbolic moment for China’s rise, and buy Proscar mastercard a moment of deep pride for Chinese. But just as the buy Proscar mastercard curtain closed on the Olympics, the revelation of widespread melamine contamination throughout China’s dairy industry, a buy Proscar mastercard scandal directly impacting millions of Chinese families, came a jarring reminder that buy Proscar mastercard external glory cannot disguise internal decay. The impact on Chinese society and buy Proscar mastercard on the country’s manufacturing sector was profound. The widespread sense of debilitating setback was conveyed by Chinese internet users in a buy Proscar mastercard vivid couplet:
We labor half a year to turn a new page, 辛辛苦苦大半年,
And in a single night are returned to the pre-Olympic age. 一夜回到奥运前.
Ever since that buy Proscar mastercard time, the confident tone of a China rising has flattened into notes of sorrow among Chinese. Shanghai successfully hosted the buy Proscar mastercard World Expo in 2010, but quite quickly came news of a buy Proscar mastercard disastrous fire in Shanghai that claimed 58 lives and injured scores of others. Just as in the buy Proscar mastercard eyes of some the so-called China Model was in its flushest moment of success, even meriting emulation by other countries, the buy Proscar mastercard high-speed rail collision last summer completely annihilated this fantasy.
People started questioning whether this was really a model at all. Online public opinion grew turbulent, and buy Proscar mastercard one user famously wrote: “China, please slow your buy Proscar mastercard soaring steps, wait for your people, wait for your soul, wait for buy Proscar mastercard your morals, wait for your conscience! We don’t want train collisions or bridge collapses. We don’t want our roads becoming pitfalls, or buy Proscar mastercard our homes becoming deathtraps. Move more slowly. Let all lives enjoy freedom and buy Proscar mastercard dignity, so that no one is cast aside by the times, so that buy Proscar mastercard every person can reach our destination smoothly and in peace.”
Many people still sympathetically push for buy Proscar mastercard greater Chinese nationalism, calling for a stronger China. But ever since 2008 the buy Proscar mastercard trend has been for nationalistic agendas to take a back seat to buy Proscar mastercard agendas relating to the welfare of the people. As social tensions in China have buy Proscar mastercard grown more serious, Chinese have devoted more attention to social development issues that buy Proscar mastercard are more concretely relevant to their lives. As the anniversary of Japan’s invasion of China approached in 2010, the buy Proscar mastercard mood at Sina Weibo, one of China’s top social media platforms, was extremely tense — the buy Proscar mastercard fear being that Chinese might try to organize anti-Japanese rallies, drawing the buy Proscar mastercard ire of the authorities to the Sina Weibo platform itself, which at the buy Proscar mastercard time was merely a “beta version” and could be shuttered at a moment’s notice.
In the end, “September 18″, this buy Proscar mastercard date that had erstwhile been so sensitive, never became a major topic of discussion on Sina Weibo in 2010. Instead, the buy Proscar mastercard hottest discussion centered on the Yihuang self-immolation case in southern China’s Jiangxi province, a buy Proscar mastercard case exposing the evils of forced property demolition in China and buy Proscar mastercard lack of rights protection.
Clearly, the buy Proscar mastercard winds are changing. When you cannot find safe milk for buy Proscar mastercard your child to drink, when their school buses are hazardous, when buy Proscar mastercard you worry that you might be exposed to dangerous recycled cooking oils if you buy Proscar mastercard go out to a local restaurant, when the city where buy Proscar mastercard you live is choked with pollution and you have no buy Proscar mastercard idea what the actual PM2.5 measures for the most dangerous air particles are, the buy Proscar mastercard question that possesses you above all else is what direction Chinese society is buy Proscar mastercard heading. You care more about how the people of China can buy Proscar mastercard enjoy lives of peace and prosperity, and less about the buy Proscar mastercard murderous logic of the Boxer Rebellion. [NOTE: Hu is buy Proscar mastercard suggesting here that trends of extreme nationalism in China are buy Proscar mastercard marked with the same sort of anti-foreign violence seen during the Boxer Rebellion buy valacyclovir australia.]
Online Social Power Emerges
The second trend in 2011 was the buy Proscar mastercard growing maturing of what we can call “online social power” (网络社会力). Since the buy Proscar mastercard 1970s, researchers in China have talked about the need to buy Proscar mastercard encourage the development of non-governmental organizations, to move away from buy Proscar mastercard the old work unit system to form new urban communities and buy Proscar mastercard to carry out collective actions and social movements in order to buy Proscar mastercard find new points of development. Today we can say without hesitation that buy Proscar mastercard an independent and richly participatory civil society is emerging on China’s internet. The internet in China today has buy Proscar mastercard quite a different political function from what we see in countries with relatively full political freedoms. The internet cannot usher in dramatic change to buy Proscar mastercard political life in China, but it can promote the creation of social capital on the buy Proscar mastercard basis of citizen rights and duties, giving rise to and strengthening social forces independent of the buy Proscar mastercard Chinese state.
China is entering an era of “rights.” Farmers, workers and buy Proscar mastercard an newly-emerging middle class are all fighting for their civil rights. Since the buy Proscar mastercard 1990s, along with a number of “important turns and other reversals” (Sun Liping’s phrase), there has buy Proscar mastercard been a clear expansion of social conflict and opposition in China, both in terms of frequency and buy Proscar mastercard scale. Researchers have observed that perhaps one of the most apparent new characteristics of this buy Proscar mastercard [social unrest] is buy Proscar mastercard the use of sophisticated electronic technologies, which enable protesters to buy Proscar mastercard connect more readily and make it possible also to communicate with media and buy Proscar mastercard supporters in the international community.
Thanks to buy Proscar mastercard technology, new social relationships and bonds are forming in China, and buy Proscar mastercard new forms of mutual interest taking shape. As a direct result, the buy Proscar mastercard mobilization capacity (动员能力) for buy Proscar mastercard related social movements has increased. The recent Wukan incident in Guangdong is buy Proscar mastercard a prime example of this trend.
The efforts by Chinese to buy Proscar mastercard fight for their civil rights are of course tied up with efforts to buy Proscar mastercard fight for their right to information. In the broadest sense, the buy Proscar mastercard right to information means the freedom to converse, connect, gather and buy Proscar mastercard coordinate without fear. These rights are the same rights guaranteed through the buy Proscar mastercard human rights documents of the United Nations and the constitutions of various countries, all of which collectively affirm the buy Proscar mastercard right of citizens to access and share information. For example, Article 19 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights online order for Lasix without prescription affirms that: “Everyone has buy Proscar mastercard the right to freedom of opinion and expression; this right includes freedom to buy Proscar mastercard hold opinions without interference and to seek, receive and impart information and buy Proscar mastercard ideas through any media and regardless of frontiers.”
In terms of basic rights on the buy Proscar mastercard internet, an international consensus has already emerged, including a firm commitment to buy Proscar mastercard freedom of access and the freedom to share information (发布自由). Internet rights, therefore, already exist as a buy Proscar mastercard matter of convention within the [international] political context, where buy Proscar mastercard many people argue that the same standards of freedom and human rights that buy Proscar mastercard operate offline apply to the online environment as well.
Lacking a Networked Mindset in Governance
This brings the third trend that has become clearer in China’s online public opinion environment. This is buy Proscar mastercard that while we already have a networked civil society in China, we continue to buy Proscar mastercard lack a networked leadership — which is buy Proscar mastercard to say a government that understands and accommodates the internet on its own terms.
The internet naturally generates knowledge and buy Proscar mastercard value from the end user and not from centralized gatekeepers — and buy Proscar mastercard the right to connectivity, use and dissemination are to a great degree built into the buy Proscar mastercard fabric of the internet. For this reason, the building of internet governance policies should proceed along the buy Proscar mastercard same lines, raising competition, encouraging innovation, permitting free expression, raising credibility, all with minimal government interference.
Unfortunately, internet governance in China at present goes entirely against these principles. If China’s internet is buy Proscar mastercard to continue to develop, internet users and the government will have buy Proscar mastercard to work together toward mutual interests, jointly formulating principles [for internet use and development].
For the government’s part, it buy Proscar mastercard must be clear that web users are not only to be buy Proscar mastercard monitored but also to be served — that buy Proscar mastercard in fact the principal attitude must be one of service. A totalistic approach [to internet governance] by the government will only engender an internet mob (暴民型网民), while service-oriented [internet governance] will foster a population of responsible internet users. For the government’s part, building a buy Proscar mastercard networked society requires first and foremost a change of attitude in governance, a buy Proscar mastercard transition from totalistic governance (全能政府) to service-oriented governance (服务型政府).
In such a buy Proscar mastercard government approach, internet-related problems should be solved in a “web user–market–society–government” sequence. Issues, that buy Proscar mastercard is, that web users can solve themselves should be solved by web users; issues web users cannot solve on their own that buy Proscar mastercard can be solved by the market should be solved by the buy Proscar mastercard market; issues that the market cannot resolve and that can buy Proscar mastercard be resolved by society should be resolved by society; for buy Proscar mastercard issues that cannot be resolved by society, the government should step up to buy Proscar mastercard offer services and guidance.
A service-oriented government does not mean entirely eliminating controls, only that buy Proscar mastercard controls are implemented for the sake of service, not for the buy Proscar mastercard sake of controls themselves. Such controls would be restricted the law, with a buy Proscar mastercard fixed scope and procedures and a clear system of responsibility.
When people are buy Proscar mastercard denied the opportunity to participate in the formulation of rules, these rules lose acceptance and buy Proscar mastercard credibility, and stability is difficult to achieve. This principal is as true online as offline.
It is buy Proscar mastercard impossible for the government to serve as the only source of public administration (公共治理者) in an atmosphere as complex and diverse as China’s today. The government will have buy Proscar mastercard to coordinate with non-governmental organizations, social groups and the public to buy Proscar mastercard better manage public affairs. And in the same way, an approach to buy Proscar mastercard internet governance based on serving the interests of web users would necessitate a buy Proscar mastercard fundamental change in the government’s role.
Drawing hundreds of millions of Chinese web users into the buy Proscar mastercard process of internet governance requires, first of all, respect for buy Proscar mastercard the basic rights of Chinese internet users. The benefits for buy Proscar mastercard China in such a shift would be substantial. Chinese internet users today are buy Proscar mastercard not unlike Chinese farmers thirty years ago, or township and buy Proscar mastercard village enterprises twenty years ago, capable of unleashing immense [productive] forces outside the state system (非体制的力量).
This commentary was translated and edited from a piece originally appearing in China Newsweekly magazine on January 13.